Buying GuidesBusiness Management

How to Run a Make or Buy Analysis Before You Outsource

A practical make or buy analysis for small businesses: the full costs to compare, the risks of outsourcing, strategic questions and a worked example.

Buying Guides: How to Run a Make or Buy Analysis Before You Outsource

Every growing business reaches the point where someone asks whether a task should stay in house or go to a supplier. It might be payroll processing, IT support, packing and shipping orders, a manufacturing step or customer support outside office hours. The question sounds simple, but the answer depends on costs that rarely appear on a single quote and on strategic factors that never appear on a spreadsheet. This guide shows you how to run a make or buy analysis that is quick enough for a small business and thorough enough to trust.

What a make or buy analysis is

A make or buy analysis compares two ways of getting the same result:

  • Make: produce the good or deliver the service with your own people, equipment and processes.
  • Buy: purchase it from an external supplier, either as a product or as an outsourced service.

The analysis has two halves. The cost half compares the total cost of each option over the same period. The strategic half asks whether the work is core to how you compete, how much control you need and how reliable the supply market is. Cost matters, but capability, risk and strategy decide whether the cheaper option is actually the better one. The Chartered Institute of Procurement and Supply (CIPS) publishes guidance on make or buy decisions if you want the professional procurement view.

There is also a third option that is often the right answer: make and buy, where you keep part of the work in house and buy the rest, or keep a small internal capability while a supplier handles volume.

Make or buy vs build vs buy

If you are deciding whether to write custom software or buy a product, use our dedicated guide to build vs buy business software. The logic is the same, but software has its own cost pattern, especially long term maintenance. This guide covers the broader decision: services, parts and whole business functions.

When to run one

Run a make or buy analysis when:

  • A supplier proposes to take over work you do today.
  • Internal capacity is full and you need to add people or equipment.
  • A key employee who does specialist work is leaving.
  • Volumes have changed sharply, up or down.
  • A supplier contract is coming up for renewal or has a large price increase.
  • You are launching a new product or service and need to decide how to deliver it.

The full cost of making

The cost of making is usually underestimated because many costs sit in general overheads rather than in the budget for the task itself.

Cost of making What to include
Direct labor Salaries, overtime, payroll taxes and benefits for the people who do the work
Materials and supplies Inputs consumed, including waste and scrap
Equipment Purchase or lease, maintenance, depreciation and eventual replacement
Space and utilities The share of rent, power and services the work uses
Management and supervision The time managers spend planning, hiring, training and checking the work
Training and turnover Onboarding new staff and the productivity lost while they learn
Quality costs Rework, returns, inspection and fixing mistakes
Software and systems Tools, licenses and IT support the work needs
Capacity cost Idle time when demand is low, or overtime and delays when it is high

A useful test is to ask: if we stopped doing this work tomorrow, which costs would actually disappear? Costs that would continue regardless, such as rent on a building you still need, should not count as savings from outsourcing. Costs that would disappear, such as a dedicated role or a lease on a machine, should.

The full cost of buying

Supplier quotes show a price, not a total cost. Add everything it takes to buy, receive and manage the work.

Cost of buying What to include
Purchase price Unit price or service fee at your realistic volumes, including minimum orders
Price changes Expected increases over the term, and how they are calculated
Selection and onboarding Time to source, evaluate and set up the supplier
Transition Knowledge transfer, parallel running and any one off fees
Freight, duties and handling Shipping, import costs, receiving and storage
Contract management Time to manage the relationship, review performance and handle disputes
Quality assurance Inspections, audits and the cost of supplier errors that reach customers
Internal coordination The people who still need to brief, check and integrate the supplier's output
Exit and switching The cost of moving to another supplier or bringing the work back in house

For price changes, ask how the supplier will adjust prices over time. Many long term contracts tie increases to a published index. The US Bureau of Labor Statistics publishes the Producer Price Index, which measures changes in the selling prices received by domestic producers, and a price adjustment guide for parties who want to write index based escalation into contracts. An index link is more predictable than "prices may change at our discretion". Our total cost of ownership guide explains how to model costs over several years, and the same approach works for services.

The strategic questions

Cost tells you which option is cheaper. These questions tell you whether cheaper is wise.

  1. Is this a core capability? If customers choose you because of this work, giving it to a supplier can weaken your advantage and hand know how to someone who may also serve your competitors.
  2. How much control do you need? Consider quality, timing, confidentiality and the ability to change the process quickly.
  3. How healthy is the supply market? Several capable suppliers mean competitive prices and a backup option. One or two suppliers mean dependence.
  4. What happens if the supplier fails? Estimate how long it would take to recover and what it would cost.
  5. Does the work involve sensitive data or regulated activity? Outsourcing moves the work, not your responsibility for it.
  6. What does the business need to get good at next? Freeing people from non core work can be worth more than the direct saving.
  7. How variable is demand? Suppliers can absorb peaks and troughs that would leave your own team overloaded or idle.

Step 1: Define the scope precisely

Write down exactly what is being compared: the output, the volume, the quality standard, the delivery time and the period. "Bookkeeping" is too vague; "monthly bookkeeping and reconciliations for two bank accounts and about 400 transactions a month, closed within ten working days of month end" is comparable. A vague scope produces quotes that cannot be compared with your internal cost.

Step 2: Calculate the current or projected cost of making

Use the cost of making table. For existing work, take real figures from payroll, invoices and the general ledger. For new work, estimate from realistic hiring costs and equipment quotes. Record each assumption in a short list so others can challenge it.

Step 3: Get real supplier quotes

Ask two or three suppliers to quote against the exact scope from Step 1. For larger or more complex work, a short request for proposal helps; our guide on how to write an RFP gives a structure. Ask each supplier how prices will change over the term, what service levels they commit to and what happens at exit.

Step 4: Build the total cost comparison

Put both options side by side over three to five years, using the same cost categories and the same volume assumptions. Include one off costs in the year they occur. If the decision is large, discount future years so that money spent later is weighted less than money spent now; for most small decisions, a simple undiscounted total is enough.

Step 5: Score the strategic factors

Score each strategic question from 1 (favors buy) to 5 (favors make), and add a short reason. Weight the factors that matter most to your business. The score does not replace judgment, but it makes the reasoning visible and stops one loud voice from deciding.

Step 6: Test the key assumptions

Identify the two or three assumptions that drive the result, usually volume, labor cost and supplier price increases, and change each one. Ask: at what volume does the answer flip? What if the supplier raises prices faster than expected? If small changes flip the decision, the two options are close and strategic factors should decide.

Step 7: Decide, document and set a review date

Record the decision, the numbers, the assumptions and the strategic reasoning in a one page memo. Set a review date, usually before the first contract renewal, and name an owner. If you buy, put service levels and exit terms in the contract; our guide on how to write a vendor SLA shows what to include.

Worked example: outsourcing order fulfilment

This illustrative model was built by the Businesslang team. A small online retailer ships about 1,500 orders a month from a back room and is considering a third party fulfilment provider. All figures are assumptions for illustration, not market quotes.

Annual cost Make (in house) Buy (outsourced)
Staff (two part time packers, with taxes and benefits) $52,000 $0
Space and utilities that would be released $14,400 $0
Packing materials $9,000 Included in fee
Software and equipment $3,600 $1,200 (integration)
Owner and manager time (5 hours a week at $60 an hour) $15,600 $6,240 (2 hours a week)
Fulfilment fees (18,000 orders at $4.50) $0 $81,000
Storage fees $0 $6,000
Year one transition cost $0 $5,000
Year one total $94,600 $99,440
Later years (no transition cost) $94,600 $94,440

Method. Each total is the sum of the stated inputs. Shipping postage is excluded because it is assumed equal under both options.

On cost alone the two options are almost identical. The decision therefore turns on the strategic factors. If the retailer expects volumes to double, the in house option would need more space and staff while the outsourced cost would scale with orders. If unboxing and packaging quality are part of the brand, keeping fulfilment in house protects them. Running the sensitivity test shows why volume matters: at 3,000 orders a month, fulfilment and storage fees double to about $174,000 a year, so outsourcing only stays competitive if growing in house would mean a larger building, more managers or a third shift. The retailer should price that expansion before deciding.

Risks of outsourcing and how to manage them

Risk How to reduce it
Quality falls Written quality standards, service levels and regular performance reviews
Supplier fails or exits Financial checks before signing, a backup supplier and an exit plan
Hidden costs grow Clear scope, a fee schedule for extras and an index based price clause
Loss of know how Keep documentation and a small internal capability for critical work
Data and compliance exposure Security questionnaire, data processing terms and audit rights
Lock in Data ownership, reasonable notice periods and a transition assistance clause

Our guide to vendor risk management covers due diligence in more depth, and a vendor scorecard gives you a simple way to track the supplier once the work moves.

Risks of keeping work in house

Making is not risk free either:

  • Key person dependence: specialist work often relies on one or two people.
  • Capacity limits: growth can outrun your team or equipment.
  • Falling behind: specialist suppliers may invest in better tools and methods than you can justify.
  • Hidden inefficiency: without a market comparison, internal costs can drift up unnoticed.

Running a make or buy analysis occasionally, even when you expect to keep the work, is a useful check on internal efficiency.

The make and buy middle path

Hybrid models often give the best balance:

  • Overflow outsourcing: keep base volume in house and send peaks to a supplier.
  • Split by complexity: keep complex or sensitive work, outsource routine work.
  • Retained expertise: outsource delivery but keep one person who understands the work well enough to manage the supplier and bring it back if needed.
  • Pilot first: outsource one product line, region or shift for a trial period before committing everything.

A one page decision memo

Use this structure to record the decision:

  1. Scope: what is being made or bought, at what volume and standard.
  2. Options compared: make, buy (named suppliers) and any hybrid.
  3. Total cost: three to five year comparison with the key figures.
  4. Strategic score: each factor with its score and reason.
  5. Sensitivity: the assumptions that would flip the decision.
  6. Decision and conditions: what was chosen and on what terms.
  7. Owner and review date: who monitors it and when it will be revisited.

Common mistakes

  • Comparing a supplier's unit price with internal labor cost alone.
  • Counting fixed overheads as savings when they will not actually go away.
  • Ignoring the internal time needed to manage a supplier.
  • Outsourcing a core capability because it looked cheaper on paper.
  • Signing without exit terms, then discovering switching is expensive.
  • Never revisiting the decision as volumes and prices change.

Bottom line

A good make or buy analysis is a total cost comparison plus a strategic check. Define the scope precisely, compare real costs over several years, test the assumptions that matter, and protect anything that makes your business different. If you decide to buy, follow our small business purchasing process and onboard the new supplier properly with our supplier onboarding guide.

Frequently asked questions

What is a make or buy analysis?

It is a structured comparison of producing a good or service internally with buying it from an external supplier. It looks at total cost, quality, capacity, risk and strategic fit, and ends with a documented decision and the assumptions behind it.

Is make or buy the same as build vs buy?

They use the same logic. Build vs buy usually refers to software, where the choice is custom development or an off the shelf product. Make or buy is the broader procurement decision and covers parts, services and whole business functions, such as bookkeeping, IT support, fulfilment or manufacturing steps.

Which costs are most often missed?

On the make side: management time, overheads such as space and utilities, idle capacity, training and the cost of quality failures. On the buy side: supplier selection and onboarding, contract management, freight and duties, price increases at renewal and the cost of switching if the supplier fails.

When should a small business keep work in house?

When the work is a core capability that customers choose you for, when it involves sensitive data or know how you do not want to share, when no reliable supplier exists, or when you have spare capacity that would otherwise sit idle.

When is outsourcing the better choice?

When the work is not core, a competitive market of capable suppliers exists, volumes are too low or too variable to justify dedicated staff or equipment, or a specialist can deliver better quality at a lower total cost.

How often should a make or buy decision be reviewed?

Review it when volumes, prices or strategy change materially, and at least before each contract renewal. A decision that was right at one volume or price can become wrong as the business grows.

Sources

  1. CIPS: Make or buy, you decide
  2. US Bureau of Labor Statistics: Price adjustment guide for contracting parties
  3. US Bureau of Labor Statistics: Producer Price Index overview

Related guidance